Leadership requires the willingness to maintain relationships and engage in dialogue, especially during moments of heightened tension and division.

We are deeply disappointed by the decision of Alberta NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi to disavow a photograph taken with Israel's Ambassador to Canada. The expectation that elected officials must apologize for a photograph in a public diplomatic interaction sets a troubling precedent and risks creating an environment where engagement itself becomes impossible.

For many in the Jewish community, this moment is particularly concerning. Interactions with Israeli representatives are increasingly being treated as inherently controversial, while diplomatic engagement with other nations is recognized as a routine and necessary responsibility of public officials. This double standard contributes to an environment where Jewish communities are singled out and where relationships that should be built through dialogue are instead discouraged.

We are also concerned that Mr. Nenshi's statement goes beyond acknowledging hurt for a photograph and represents a one-sided and harmful accusation against Israel. These statements legitimize hostility toward Israel and fuel antisemitism. Actions like this make Alberta Jewish communities feel increasingly isolated and targeted. We reject the idea that a choice must be made between supporting Palestinian civilians and standing against antisemitism. Albertans can hold compassion for innocent lives on all sides while unequivocally condemning terrorism and opposing the alarming rise in antisemitism here at home.

At a time when antisemitism and polarization are ever present, we need leaders who are willing to foster understanding, not retreat from it. Political leaders should be judged by their willingness to engage responsibly, represent all constituents, and uphold the democratic values that allow for dialogue, disagreement, and diplomacy. This is not about a photo; it’s about whether elected leaders are prepared to engage respectfully. We reject any narrative that suggests engagement with Israeli officials means otherwise.

We remind the Official Leader of the Opposition and all elected officials that engaging in conversation is a fundamental part of leadership. We remain committed to dialogue, mutual respect, and building an Alberta where every community feels safe, heard and valued.

Stacey Leavitt-Wright
CEO | Jewish Federation of Edmonton

Rob Nagus
CEO | Calgary Jewish Federation

Marley Gillies
Senior Director, Alberta | Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs